The overwhealming reason to measure recipe ingredients by weight instead of by volume is precision and repeatability. If you measure by weight, the amount of a particular ingredient is not affected by how tightly it is packed, how finely it is chopped, whether it is a large, medium, or small item, whether it is precisely leveled in the measuring cup, which country your measuring cup comes from (U.S.cup = 237 milliliters, U.K.cup = 284 milliliters, and Australia cup= 250 milliliters), or what brand of flour you are using. The number one complaint of home cooks is that they followed a recipe, but it didn’t turn out. The reason is that while they used the same number of cups of each ingredient as the recipe author, they actually used a different amount. If you have experienced this frustration first hand, and are now ready to try a modern digital kitchen scale using the latest load cell technology, you still need to knowhow to use your kitchen scale effectively.
Before doing anything else with your kitchen scale, you must tare it properly. Taring means eliminating the weight of the scales’s bowl from the weight of the food item it contains. Put the empty bowl on the scale by itself. On digital scales this is trivially easy–there will be a tare button which will reset the scale to zero.
Once you are ready to use your scale, you may find it difficult to find recipes that list ingredients by weight instead of volume. If you have a cookbook published in Europe, this is no problem. It is common in Europe to measure dry ingredients by weight and liquid ingredients by volume. But if you live in the United States, you already know that cookbooks usually list ingredients by volume. What do you do?
Of course you could purchase a European cookbook. The downside to this is that it may not contain the recipes you want, and if you have been cooking for any length of time, you probably have notes written around your favorite recipes detailing variations that you do not want to lose. Here’s how you can convert recipes that call for cup measures to more reliable and repeatable weight-based recipes. This approach assumes that you have tried and were satisfied with the recipe. Converting your ingredients to weight will make sure that the recipe will turn out the same every single time you make it, and has the added benefit of making sure that anyone you share the recipe with, will get the same results you do.
To convert a recipe, fill your cup measure with the same two cups of flour you always use, packed exactly as you always pack it, and then dump it into a pre-tared weighing bowl on your scale and note the weight on the original recipe. Repeat for each dry ingredient. Now you are done because liquids are best measured by volume anyway. If your recipe doesn’t come out quite right, no problem. You still know exactly how much of each ingredient you used in the botched attempt. It’s much easier to use a little more or less of a particular ingredient when you know precisely how much you used before. With the variation inherent in cup measures, this would be almost impossible.
Weighing each ingredient as you go is not the only way to determine their weight. If you cook more by appearance and texture than by weight, adding a few extra tablespoons of this ingredient or that, you can still figure out how much of each ingredient you used by using the difference method.
First gather your ingredients, leaving them in their storage containers. Now weigh each container. Don’t worry about taring the scale with an empty container first; just record the weight of the container with its contents.
Next, actually cook your dish. After you have finished cooking, assuming you like the results, weigh each of the ingredient storage containers again. Subtract the after-cooking weight of each container from the before-cooking weight to determine how much of the ingredient you used.
The difference method is also great for reconstructing secret or unknown recipes, like your grandma’s famous cornbread. She may not use a recipe at all, or it may be one that only makes sense to her. It may call for 2 regular scoops of flour, but only she knows which scoop that means and how to pack it. If you weigh her flour before and after the biscuit making, you’ll know exactly how much she uses.
Using a kitchen scale not only makes it possible to recreate a recipe precisely as you made if before, it can save you some time. The idea is that instead of pouring each ingredient out of the weighing bowl into your mixing bowl after weighing, you simply re-tare the scale and load the next ingredient right on top.
Now that you have your favorite recipes converted to weight-based recipes, you can get excited about making your grandma’s famous cornbread and be pretty certain that it is going to come out right.